Columbus, OH – Building the Startup Ecosystem

Today’s post comes by way of Brian Zuercher, the CEO of FlyMuch.com in Columbus, Ohio. In it, he describes his experience returning to Columbus as an entrepreneur four years ago, some background on Columbus, and two specific lessons that he’s learned: (1) stop trying to be Silicon Valley and (b) take the long view.

Reid Hoffman describes entrepreneurship as jumping off a cliff and assembling the plane on the way down, and this seems to hold true for entrepreneurship no matter where you live. The difference for an entrepreneur in Columbus, who decides to jump off the cliff, is that he or she will also need to wear the hat of entrepreneurial eco-system builder. In other words, the entrepreneurs need to assemble the plane, and source all the parts (recruit crazy people to work for you), find thermal updraft (funding), and convince some passengers to ride this extremely risky flight (evangelists, government, etc.).

It’s been almost four years since I returned to Columbus after a decade gone for school, work and more school. We returned to Columbus for many of the reasons people return to where they grew up. The one difference in my thought process, albeit naïve maybe, was that I believed you could start a company anywhere and make it happen.

Now that I am in my 4th year back, I know what is in front of me and it’s a decision many entrepreneurs in Columbus and cities like Columbus will face. Entreperneurs will have to wear two hats for their foreseeable future. One hat is that of the entrepreneur for their company and the second hat is that of the entrepreneur for their community. The main challenge this creates for entrepreneurs is time and stamina. The difficulties and stress associated with entrepreneurship are already tough, so the key is to know the hurdles in front of you before you start.

First, a little background on Columbus.

Columbus, OH has many of the ingredients that are not easily replicated in other cities. We have one of the largest universities in the country in The Ohio State University, a relatively large base of experienced corporate IT staff, and generally a nice (lower cost) place to live. With the exception of mountains or an ocean, we are ahead of most cities that are trying to build entrepreneurial eco-systems.

There is a unique size to cities like Columbus. Cities like Columbus that have just shy of a million people in the city and another half million in the metro area, have a small enough size that navigating the network to find people is still relatively easy, but still enough people to warrant corporate investment and workforce build.

Within two weeks of my return to Columbus I had coffee with an incubator representative, attended Startup Weekend, and created my first company. The problem in cities like this is not getting to the right people; it’s what happens next. We started our company and had revenue and traction in the first few months. This sounds like a story most entrepreneur’s dream of. The challenges started when there was really nowhere for us to go after that. We tried to get some local incubator funding, but the committees voting were scared of web market and it’s uncertainty. Additionally, most angels in Columbus had backgrounds as Doctors, Lawyers, Corporate Execs, etc., but not as ground up entrepreneurs, which ultimately meant they were extremely risk averse and not interested in funding any deals that did not have obvious cash flow break-even tangible products.

It’s easy to get frustrated when you get into these situations. The easy answer is to just move to somewhere like Silicon Valley where the ‘get it’ crowd around new tech and funding is already at critical mass. There is a ton of bad logic in making a decision like that, and I continually fight my own pull towards it.

There are two lessons I have taken away from my early experiences in Columbus.

1. Stop trying to be Silicon Valley. Columbus is constantly being ranked the ‘Next big tech city’ or whatever. It makes me want to vomit when I hear this, because inevitably the next week some local paper says puts out a headline that says, “Is Columbus the next Silicon Valley?”. The answer is and should be NO. Columbus is going to be – Columbus version 2.0. It is our job to stay true to the steady, smart backbone that built cities like Columbus, but begin to shift the future economic engine to entrepreneurship. One nice thing about Columbus is its lack of parochialism. Most people ‘from Columbus’ are first generational. The city was relatively small until the 70’s and 80’s, so the benefit is a lack of legacy rewriting. The community is ready for chapter 2 to be written, but it’s not going to be the next Silicon Valley (unless you can move some mountains and an ocean closer).

2. Take the long view. We do not live in a long-view world, so making investments today that will have maturity years from now is really painful. Most people think it’s the money, government or big wins that will make the eco-system build. I would argue the longest and most painful, but ultimately the most important ingredient is Culture. We are trying to change generational thought processes of risk, process and opportunity and it doesn’t happen overnight. To take the long-view you need to celebrate the wins incrementally and set achievable goals that don’t jeopardize the long-term progress.

Finally, some signs of progress.

We recently started WakeUp StartUp, a monthly pitch breakfast for entrepreneurs. What is unique about this meetup is that there is only one requirement: you need an ASK. The ASK doesn’t have to be funding, it can be customers, employees, advice, etc. The first two events we maxed out the venue and it’s continuing to grow with submissions and attendance. The most important aspect of WakeUp StartUp is that the entrepreneurs run it.

I am bullish on new entrepreneurial eco-systems and the people building them. My advice to entrepreneurs is to treat your community like a startup your investing in. This let’s you transfer your hats you have to wear a little more smoothly.

Our motto here is “why the hell not Columbus.”


5 Comments on “Columbus, OH – Building the Startup Ecosystem”

  1. grantalan says:

    Thanks Brad. This is exactly the kind of thing I need to hear. Being in Bloomington that has been going on for a while now as began by Brad Wisler, Mike Trotzke, and Marc Guyer of Sproutbox.
    Myself being originally from South Bend, IN, I want to live where my family is and have a healthy entrepreneurial ecosystem there. It has begun in South Bend from what I hear and I want to be a part of the continued effort of 20+ years to grow the community again. …again because the cars our grandparents drove, Studabakers, were all made in South Bend, Indiana. I am proud of the heritage of the city and want to help create a place where ideas can thrive again.
    You are an inspiration to me. Your work with David Cohen and your involvement in empowering young people to follow their dreams.

  2. Brian,
    Great point of view – certainly Brad has written a ton about Boulder. Things picked-up when Brad got here bringing with him some seed funding, the social venture partners model, and YEO, now EO, from his days Boston. It was the culture that Brad watered and fertilized. I got to Boulder in 1983 after high-school in Cincinnati. I would say Boulder has been executing on your two points for the last 17 years thanks to many who just want to stay here and make it great. You nailed it.

    The pull for Boulder to be a bedroom community of Silicon Valley is scary – only 2 hours away by plane. Be thankful you don’t have to fight that dynamic:) Lots of people in service to the Silicon Valley business and just living in Boulder, not really serving the Boulder community.

    Good luck in Columbus with leveraging your context to make Columbus 2.0. I believe most of the large intractable social problems of the world will need to be solved with local solutions that are appropriate for the context. Your approach seems the only way forward to creating that culture that breads a strong community both economically, socially and even environmentally.

    Ryan

  3. Marshall Hargrave says:

    Great material as always Brad, whether it’s here or over at feld.com.

    Brian, I enjoyed your perspective. I have recently found myself living in Columbus and in the year I have been here I have managed to notice the lack of VC interest. There is no shortage of financial services companies, including myself, where I run an investment management company, but have found myself much more interested in financial consulting for start-ups. The VCs that are based in Columbus appear to have no real, or dedicated interest in technology, and if they do invest in technology it appears to be centered around healthcare. There is TechColumbus, which seems to be almost overwhelming.

    I do understand the strong medical presence at OSU, but there are still plenty of entrepreneurs flowing into and out of the university that are doing interesting things outside of healthcare. I cannot see Columbus ever becoming the next Silicon Valley, nor would I want that, but it would be nice to see some interest in harboring the entrepreneurial spirit of all types that Columbus has, either from VCs or angels.

    Thanks again.

    Marshall

  4. [...] Cameron, I believe my job is both building startups and building our local community. Like Brian, I have focused on the “long-view” and never wanted us to try to become the next Silicon [...]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 149 other followers